NZ Idol 1: What tha heck is karly doing!!!!

Submitted by lolez on 23 February, 2004 - 5:45pm

r tha judges blind she can't sing and she can't dance and to be onest WTF is up with her moves and i used to like that not that kinda girl song by anastasia but now bro i h8 ever since she sung i'll never be able 2 listen to that song again coz she honestly killed it. someone pleze teach her sum dance moves before she goez 2 far and nzidol will be disgraced........

Comment

I couldn't agree more.....she looks like she should be in Kiddie-Idol. Her nasal voice makes me feel like vomiting and she's way too over-confident

Comment

Are you kidding me? She looks like she got her dance moves of Hi 5 and if she pushed her voice out of her nose anymore it'll fall off like Michael Jacksons

Comment

Karly is not an idol....shes young and it shows! Stop it with the dance moves.....and get rid of the nasally voice.....its bad!!!!

Comment

Woo hoo!! she didn't make it! YeE HAHHH!!

Comment

mmmmm, you guys are so nice to Karly.

Well done for negativity

Comment

hey im jus tryna tell tha truth coz im glad dat she got out of da comp, well actually how did she evn get into the comp shux, evri1 knows she cant sing let alone dance she shud be da lead dancer 4 hi 5 even nathan tha dude of hi 5 got beta moves...

Comment

LOLEZ U SOUND ABOUT 14? AND A FIA G DOGG?

Comment

look im jus tryna tell da truth and if u don't like it sori but she hasn't got tha voice i mean she don't evn hav dat look and im older than 14 try above 18 and i ain't no fie g dogg wateva u mean by dat g...........

Comment

Yeah lolez and thats why you were picked for a judge right? You are just SO qualified to talk. NOT!

Comment

hey n u no it!!!i bet dat u r frenz wif her but honest SHE CANT SING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11FULLSTOP dea was moa peeps hu cud she only in coz of her freakin performance so GET OVERIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Comment

LoL... Karly made it that far cause of her stage performance where-as her voice kinda got her down a bit cause I could most definately hear singing through her nose but that was only when she sang high notes. When she wasnt singing a high note, she sounded pretty good... but when she sang Janet Jacksons song during the theatre round where she let her hair down, it raised an eyebrow for me... like, WHAT DA?? but yeah, thats all.

Comment

took a while lolez........

Comment

yea n u no it!!!!!! she sings from her nose OBVIOUSLY!!!!!! man i'm not tryna b dat much h8ing on her.........GET OVER IT!!!!

Comment

Let's just all be thankful she didn't make it in...

Comment

OH my god!! Get a life. she IS young- so no wonder she doesn't act like stuck up crusty Camilla (whos way too old to be an idol)
She also is one of the top singers, AND dancers in the country- shes been doing both since she was little and had the best singing and dancing teachers in the country, so get off your fat ** and do something else cos you obviously don't know what your taking about. And because she is young, you guys should be more considerate, don't you think her 16yo heart is breaking when she reads this- it was so hard for her to do this, so ease off on the mean. PS, she sung through her nose cos she was sick, she doesn't normally, Paul told her that she sung the Janet Jackson song better than Janet Jackson so she must be doing something right. GET A LIFE, STOP HURTING HER FEELINGS - kARLY, I KNOW YOULL READ THIS SO JUST DON'T WORRY ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING, YOUR ARE BETTER THAT NZPUPPET ANYWAY. LOVE EM.

Comment

kARLY YOU KNOW YOU DIDN'T DO YOUR BEST, BUT IT DOESN'T MATTER. WE LOVE YOU, THE PEOPLE THAT WRITE THIS DON'T KNOW ANYTHING, YOU HAVE HAD THE BEST TEACHERS IN THE COUNTRY, EVEN THE nZiDOL SINGING COACH THOUGHT YOU'D GET IN- SO DNT WORRY, THEY KNOW MORE THAN THESE STUPID, HEARTLESS PEOPLE. dON'T LET THIS GET TO YOU.

Comment

Hey man thats your opinion and if uyou dont like the way people are talking about her how can you go out and talk about someone else.
Camillia is an awesome person i work with her brother and she'll be hurt about what you've just written if you honestly cared about your friend or whatever you wouldnt have let her enter the compettition.
Good on her for getting this far she was kinda bad though but its all just constructive criticsm thats all.
if she was meant for t.v she will pick herself up and try again.

Comment

IM GONA KEEP WRITING UNTIL THERE IS MORE GOOD THAN BAD. IM NOT LETTING YOU GUYS BREAK THE SOAL OF A NICE AND TALENTED GIRL. sHE DOES NOT HAVE TOO MUCH CONFIDENCE EITHER, SHES SHY, BUT IM SURE YOU GUYS HAVE DESTROYED WHATEVER SHE HAD LEFT. THANKS A LOT.

Comment

ples dont say that she can improve just because she young. You can be young and still have a good voice! Christina Aguilera recorded the song 'Reflections' at age 16 and sung 'Another Sad Love Song' note perfect at age 13 she has sounded the same since she was 10 (except now more mature). Age has nuthing to do with it.

Comment

Who cares? Shes gone and thats all that matters.

Lifes a beach and then you drown.

Comment

hEY NEXTDOOR, YOU SOUND LIKE A HOTTIE.... HEHE, YOUR THE ONLY ONE ON HERE THAT knows WHAT THEY TALKING ABOUT- AND YES, WE DO know. THESE PEOPLE JUST SIT ON THERE ** AND JUDGE SOMEONE FOR TRYING HER BEST AT SOMETHING.
at least she did move, everyone else just stood there, looking like they just pee'd their pants and were so afraid to move coz theyd leave a urine trail.

Comment

um singa boi, yay for your christina aguilera information, but i never said anything about that. people were saying she she was young and it shows and i was saying, no **.
age has nothing to do with it, but experience does.

Comment

yea hu r u 2 say dat camilla iz way too old to be in idol shux u fink dat shez old....bro KARLY SUX END OF THE STORY, i don't care if shez reading this coz yea she had dat much potential to get in the top 60 and 24 but hu wud fink she wud actually make it to the top 10.........pfft..........dats a laugh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Comment

I don't care that she didn't get in, im glad she didnt, i just don't see the point in you guys starting up a club to talk about how bad she was, she will be reading this, and she is going to be so embarrised and hurt. Yeah, its all part of show business, but you guys need to ease off a bit.

Comment

bro datz wot this whole thing is about so if u don't like it move along to another discussion place, if u didn't care if she got in then y were u jus sayin all dat stuff about paul saying she could sing better then janet jackson obviously hez neva herd talent when he seez it WTF is he a judge for then, wen he sed no to camillia da man is deaf.......

Comment

mtk girl, i didn't mean to piss you off, or hurt Camillas feellings. im just getting fired up. Camilla is one of the best in the competition, my point in calling her old is, that everyone has faults in this competition, i just don't see the point in making a page about it. Its not constuctive criticism when it gets as petty as some off this stuff has been.

Comment

we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly, we love you karly.

Comment

fear enough look man you are right some of this stuff is pretty harsh and good on you for trying to stick up for her or whatever it is that your doing but honestly everyone does think diffrently and they will state their opinions whether we like it or not.

Comment

lolez... yeah, he wouldn't know talent when he saw it eh... maybe you should take his job, cos you know everything. I bet hes trembling in his shoes.
im not saying i think she should make the top 10, maybe you should start learning to read instead of sitting around on your ass talking about someone you don't know so badly, shes out of the comp, and your all happy, so why continue to badmouth her.

Comment

yeah, i know that mtkgirl, im just tryna write some nice stuff cos i know shes gona be hurting so bad when she reads this, youd probly do the same for Camilla if they made a hater page about her.

Comment

LoL @ EVERYONE!!!!

Oh my gosh, I go away for like, 24 hours and people are all talkin bout how much they love/don't love Karly?? Even tho she's been voted off and already getting on with her very successful life??

I mean I DID have a problem with the way she sang, but reading this i think you have all changed my friggin mind...

first of all, she is NOT as bad as ur overuse of superlatives states. In no way do I believe that she had absolutely NO talent.

In fact, she is much better than HEEEAPS of people i know, and shows the confidence and maturity of someone far far older than she actually is.

That kind of talent goes a LONG way, and its something that most of us who sit at home and literally kick a person when they're down will never really understand.

As for the bit when she said 'Yes i am' (you all remember that bit), I would pass it off as 'Camera Nerves'. I admit, her dancing may have not been 'Superstar Standard' but at least she made it in and gave it a shot nevertheless.

She may be a bitch in real life but that aint for us to judge. We all gots our faults.

Some people are stuck up. Some people need to make themselves feel big by putting others down. Some just have boring lives and nothing better to do than sit on NZ Idol Forums all day(Points at self :D)

Any way it goes, the fact of the matter is this - Karly made it to the top 24 and got voted off because she wasn't good enuff. Not because she WASN'T good, just others were better.

Like Cam, Benny + Filipo :P

So cheer up guys, its all over!!! If u got nightmares, bringing them up is just gonna keep em comin back :P

LmAoOo!!!

GO NZ IDOL 2004!!!

Comment

hey millie i understand how u mus feel bout ur m8 yea n i posted this message wen she was still on yea she got a bit of talent on da stage but i ddnt mean to piss u off so sori bro i fink we shud jus end all things here and stop coz dis jus gon keep goin and yea i jus wanted to know if any1 else felt the same n sum do and sum dont so to end dis lil discussion and stop millie from getting pissed of all the freakin time.i jus kept writing to make ma point and now i hav but people DON'T GET THE MESSAGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! okay thanx...........

Comment

hahaha @ Barney's comment i'll second that!

Comment

Karly is a superstar, Karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar, karly is a superstar... hi Millie!

Comment

Karly is a superstar in Paraparaumu

Comment

my mom said that karly looks like linda blair in the exorcist hahahahah

Comment

Glad that trick is gone...
Peace, Love & Hair Grease...

Listening To Van Halen - "Fire In The Hole"

Comment

Millie, youre typing as if youre Karly herself. If you dont like people saying bad things about her or whatever then why are you saying nasty things about Camillia?? She just wasnt good enough for most NZlanders otherwise she wouldve still been in. Look, she was good... but not good enough. Just bite the dust girl, and grab a box of Kleenex or something. Shes gone goodbyebye. So say goodbyebye cause having you sulk about her leaving aint gonna bring the nose singer back.

Comment

she'll be back for the wildcard for sure.

Comment

yea i freakin reckon,i agree wif joey82 if u r wada no life nose singer aint coming back and if she does cme back for the wildcard which i doubt she jus gon' get h8ed even moa so byebyebyebyebye shez freakin gone...........

My discussions