General: Jackie Clarke not a judge

Submitted by admin on 16 March, 2006 - 11:58am

Someone sent me a tipoff that Jackie has been "dumped" as a judge this year. We'll try and find out what the story is.

If you know any info to clarify this, please let us know.

Jackie was on B&B (Maori TV)

Jackie was on B&B (Maori TV) last night, singing and acting.  She sang some Maori song - to do with Anzac Day - very beautifully.  She sure can sing.

I really liked Jackie, as

I really liked Jackie, as long as someone from TrueBliss doesnt end up getting it.
Jackie and Fiona both fitted the "woman singer" role that seems to be a part of the Idol format, so who is going to be the new one? hmmmmmmmm...

well you're going to be

well you're going to be disappointed ...... look out for Joe Cotton

I like Joe Cotton!! But i

I like Joe Cotton!! But i havnt seen her around for a while.

LMAO! When ever I see her

LMAO! When ever I see her name I always imagine a 'ball' at the end. Joe Cotton Ball!

Hahahahahahahaha!!! LMAO

Hahahahahahahaha!!! :P

LMAO

who is taking Jackie's

who is taking Jackie's position as a judge of IDOL 3 and Paul Ellis?

Reag and Rach

Reag and Rach

Don't know where else to put

Don't know where else to put this, so will put it here under a 'Jackie' discussion!

Saw Jackie in a Broadway tribute show in Palmy at the weekend.  She was brilliant.  Never before appreciated what an outstanding singer and performer she is!  Fantastic personality and voice that goes with show songs so well.  Can understand every word  she's singing too.:)

Excellent show right through, with dancers, choir and including one of my favourite show singers - Chris Crowe. All held together amazingly by Jackie!:)

Oh cool that's good

Oh cool that's good :)

i heard that Stables from ZM

i heard that Stables from ZM is taking her place!

Jackie's in Palmerston North

Jackie's in Palmerston North at the moment, performing in a 'Broadway' show - which I'm going to see on Sat.

Anyway, she was on the radio (More) this morning and said the reason she's not judging thhis year is because though she did enjoy it, she felt a second time wouldn't be so good for her, and she wants to concentrate on singing.

The DJ (Mike) said the standard of the contestants last year was no where near as high as the first time and wondered what we would get this year.

Jackie said the talent here is more 'raw' that we see in America, like real beginers just having a go. If ours are 'raw' then what on earth are those we're seeing on American Idol at the moment!:?

How about just not do NZ

How about just not do NZ Idol!!!

or just get a new . . . . . .everything!

new judges

new presenter

new stage

EVERYTHING!!

Oooh a new stage would be

Oooh a new stage would be great!

They shouldn't just add a new bit here and there each season. They should create a big fancy new one, with flash lighting and effects.

One that looks full of adventures, with the "wow" factor.

Why don't they kick Frankie

Why don't they kick Frankie off too? Get an entirely new panel of judges..

..all Idolbloggers would be a good start...

Haha I can so see TC being a

Haha I can so see TC being a judge and having an arugement with Dom about going to tvnz.co.nz keyword nz idol :p

Just a thought....

it wouldn't be an argument.

it wouldn't be an argument. It would be a *cough*Idolblog.com*cough* as he said the other one

Lol awesome. TC for

Lol awesome. TC for president! :D *is on a high*

i agree get rid of frankie

i agree get rid of frankie he annoys me sooo much!!

No, I like Frankie, the best

No, I like Frankie, the best one!  Definately think he's an asset!:)

I think we should have a

I think we should have a "suggest a replacement for Jackie Clarke" thread too, like we have for Paul Ellis ;) 

Oh really dumb! She is a

Oh really dumb! She is a kool person!

She may be a kool person,

She may be a kool person, but she was too nice, and loved everyone in the later stages without giving constructive criticism!

They need someone who's going to push them to do better, not love whatever they do.

Fiona's the one to do that - and she's a kool person too!:)

Yeah but surely they need

Yeah but surely they need some positive flirty feed-back lol. I don't know why but Fiona just does not do it for me!

Yea! I think my problem is i

Yea! I think my problem is i do not like change. I try and hold on to things so they don't change but it always works out anyway. I wasnt impressed when Fiona left and now i don't want jackie to leave. And really Idol needs alot to change lol.

Jackie was good for one

Jackie was good for one season, otherwise not.

Jackie just didnt throw out

Jackie just didnt throw out enuff personal insults like Fiona did. thats why she was given the boot!

Fiona should be put back in to throw out the personal insults to all the losers. its good when Judges bring their home/family BS to idol and take it out on the miss-fits  hahaha

That's the exact reason why

That's the exact reason why Fiona was a crap judge.

exactly

exactly

Aw man I like Jackie and

Aw man I like Jackie and shes cool in person :D

I like to see Louise Wallace

I like to see Louise Wallace give it a crack - "You are the weakest Idol, goodbye".

If Louise Wallace wants

If Louise Wallace wants crack she just heads over to Darren MacDonald's house...

They better get someone

They better get someone cool.

Like me.

Or me.

me is an option.

and me too.

anyone one of the above.

*Starts a petition* WE WANT

*Starts a petition* WE WANT BARNEY !  WE WANT BARNEY!  8)

I would like to see Fiona

I would like to see Fiona Back too.....:)

. Dumb!! I like her.

:O. Dumb!! I like her.

Awww...be nicer to

Awww...be nicer to yourself.
.
.
.
You're not dumb because you like Jackie Clarke :-)

My brother heard Frankie on

My brother heard Frankie on the radio saying he was the only Judge coming back this year.

Just thinking about this ...

Just thinking about this ... if Frankie was heard to say he was the only judge coming "back" this year, that would mean Fiona won't be coming "back" either ... it will definitely be someone new ;) 

Just a thought ...

Very True!

:o

Very True!

Oh yay - that's cool

Oh yay - that's cool 8)

C'mon Admin don't be so

C'mon Admin don't be so bashful, just come out and say it.
"TVNZ has dumped Jackie Clarke for me, Rachel Cunliffe!"

Damn, I was my own secret

Damn, I was my own secret source?

lol, sneaky

lol, sneaky :p

Well, that wouldn't be such

Well, that wouldn't be such a bad idea!:)

Agreed!

Agreed! :)

Don't know, but I'd like to

Don't know, but I'd like to see Fiona back!  Jackie was too nice and loved everyone too much!

My discussions